Tea Party Snark III: Working-Class Schlubs, Abnormal Teabaggers
A continuing series covering snarky, condescending and inappropriate liberal response to the Tea Party Movement. Snark I | Snark II
David Neiwert closes his eyes and flails his arms while running at the Tea Party movement, calling it “populist.” Well, duh, of course it’s populist. Neiwert thinks, however, that right-wing populism “in the process of taking the reins of the leaderless conservative movement,” calling it “sucker populism” as though left-wing populism is somehow less impetuous. I would guess that right-wing populism has approximately the same hold over conservatives as left-wing populism has over Obama’s liberal establishment. If you want to really understand populism go here.
Neiwert prattles on until he gets to this juicy part:
It is, in essence, predicated on the psychology of celebrity-worship: convincing working-class schlubs that they too can someday become rich and famous too — because when they do, would they want to be taxed heavily? It’s all about dangling that lottery carrot out there for the poor stiffs who were never any good at math to begin with.
My, my, isn’t that interesting? Neiwert looks down his fancy-pants liberal nose at “working-class schlubs” who have no chance whatsoever to “become rich and famous.” Those “poor stiffs” who aren’t “any good at math to begin with.” How… condescending.
Neiwert inadvertently reveals the crux of modern liberalism: that we poor “schlubs” need the the know-it-all liberals to rescue us from ourselves.
**********
Thers at Firedoglake snarks directly at Tea Party protesters saying, “Hey, Tea-Baggers — you’re not the majority; hell, you’re not even normal”
Thers is referring to the “Slient Majority No More,” saying there is NO WAY the Tea Party’s anti tax, anti-spending message could be representative of a majority of Americans:
There are no poll data whatsoever to support the idea that Americans are Fed Up when it comes to taxes.
Uhhh. Yes there is. Great job on the fact checking, there Thers.
The Gallup Poll Thers, the Washington Post and rest of the Liberalati are touting shows that:
48% of Americans saying the amount of federal income taxes they pay is “about right,” with 46% saying “too high”
That’s with a ±3% margin of error, of course.
But wait – this survey includes ALL Americans. I wonder, just wonder what the numbers would look like if you asked only those who actually pay income taxes? Hmmmm…
Thers goes on to snark at Tea Party protesters some more:
The Grandma-haired Byron York went to one of these small-town tea-bags, like I did, though, as he says, “organizers posted a note on their website asking that everyone “Please DO NOT personally attack the President or any member of Congress by name” — as it was a classic conservative Republican, limited-government, anti-spending talkfest.” Well, when you’re told top-down what the message is, it cleans up real good, I guess. But everywhere else, Glenn Beck won, it was all very wingnutty sloganeering, and well, good luck building a winning electoral coalition on that, Republicans.
So it’s bad to encourage civility and respect when protesting???? I think Thers is upset at being denied the opportunity to snark at protesters who may have otherwise been disrespectful.
So, I guess it’s abnormal a) to be upset at wasteful government spending and over-taxation b) to believe that most people don’t like wasteful government spending and over-taxation c) to protest about it and d) to be respectful while protesting.
Waking the Sleeping Giant: Nationwide Tax Protest Tea Party Attendance Exceeds 1 Million « Frugal Café Blog Zone said,
April 17, 2009 at 1:18 pm
[...] White House Says Obama ‘Unaware’ of Tea Parties The Crowbar: Tea Party Snark III: Working-Class Schlubs, Abnormal Teabaggers Michelle Malkin: Massive: Tax Day Tea Party USA; Updated Moderate in the Middle: Update: Arizona [...]
David Neiwert said,
April 17, 2009 at 11:01 pm
Dude, I am a working-class stiff. 4th-generation Idahoan, worked on potato farms thru hi school, did road construction to put myself thru college, have extended working-class family in Idaho and Montana still.
You might wanna know whereof you speak before you post this tripe.
Ben Grivno said,
April 18, 2009 at 1:06 am
My post is hardly tripe. Most people reading your post on C&L aren’t going to bother to look your background up – are you certain they’re not interpreting your words as I did?
Your background makes the real question more poignant. Your point, I now believe, is that the conservative tactic is to cynically manipulate working-class stiffs, to give them a sense of false hope. But, by arguing this are you not conceding there is no real hope for them to “become rich and famous” in the first place? Are you implying the working-class stiffs who have those dreams are just fooling themselves?
So you know, I am also a working-class stiff from a working class family in Minnesota so I am personally invested in that question.
The Million Taxpayer March The Revolution Started April 15 2009 USA TERM LIMITS 2 TERMS PETITION ALL 50 STATES NATIONWIDE LOCAL STATE FEDERAL HOUSE SENATE | Washington DC Tea Party.com Blogs Blog In 9/12/2009 - 9/14/2009 Join Now said,
April 20, 2009 at 2:53 am
[...] Tea Party Snark III: Working-Class Schlubs, Abnormal Teabaggers « The Crowbar [...]